Saturday, October 24, 2020
Homepage - Start here...
log in  •  join

Current Password:
New Password: (5 Char Min)
Confirm New Password:

User name (email)
Remember Me:
Forgot Password?
| Home
Shuls & Tefillos
Contact Us
 Browse the directory by:
Business Listings
Search the directory for:
Important Numbers

Doctors and Physicians (13)
Emergency Numbers (12)
Hospitals (22)
Pharmacy (20)
Pharmacy - 24 Hours (4)
Pharmacy - Midnight (15)
Shatnez (1)
Toronto Jewish Social Services (0)
Walk-in Clinics (2)

FRUMToronto Topics

 Audio and PDF's:
Rabbi Ganzweig>
Weekly Publications>
Articles of Interest (218)
Ask The Rabbi (2908)
Bulletins & Alerts (5)
Community Events Blog (23)
Frum Toronto Staff (2)
Gut Shabbos & Gut Yom Tov (63)
Inspirational Stories (7)
Kuntrus Ramach Avarim (2)
Message Board (19)
Parenting (149)
Parsha Pearls (459)
Readers Recipes (4)
Shemiras Halashon (178)
Shmiras Haloshon Yomi (128)
Special Prayers (34)
Tehillim (99)
Thoughts for the Week (191)

FRUMToronto Links

Advertising Rates>
Eruv Toronto>

FRUMToronto Articles Ask The Rabbi

Have a question? Send it in! Questions are answered by Rabbi Bartfeld.

Blog Image: AskTheRabbi.jpg
# 1344 A Walk In The Park
Q. Can I carry items in a park inside a city that has an eiruv on Shabbos? Does it make a difference how big the park is? If it is surrounded by a fence and has gates? If it has benches, many trees or water fountains?

A. Poskim (Chelkas Yaakov1: 201, Orchois Chaim 358, 10-11, Shemiras Shabbos Kehilchoso N.E. 17: 118) maintain that if there is an eiruv that surrounds the city, you may carry on the parks included in the eiruv area. The above applies, even if they are larger than an area of beis sossaim (5000 sq. amos or approximately 1250 sq. meters) and could be considered the karfaf that our Sages banned carrying an object within, when it was dedicated for non-habitation purposes, and was not initially walled as part of a residence. (eino hukaf ledira).
The reason these Poskim permit is that parks are land that was set aside for public use, and is maintained for recreational and ornamental purposes. A public park is frequented by the public who sit on the benches, play on the grass or enjoy the walk and the view, therefore it would be considered hukaf ledirah. (See Chazon Ish Maasros 5: 8. Orchois Chaim ibid. quotes Poskim that disagree)
Although Shulchan Aruch (O.H. 358:1) rules that gardens and orchards are not considered hukaf ledirah. it refers to gardens and orchards that are fenced to protect their fruit and not for public use.
Biur Halachah (ibid.) explains why a “dir” used for protecting animals is considered hukaf ledirah more than gardens and orchards. See Noda Beyehuda (2: 47), and Maase Oreg p. 137 on carrying in a Zoo. Imrei Yosher (2: 80) quoting Beis Meir.
Horav Shlomo Miller’s Shlit’a opinion is to be lenient for the ones who in general use an eiruv. It is also a widely accepted view today. The Rov added that although some large parks, have areas that people cannot walk on them because of the planted flowers, flora or the thickness of the shrubs, since they are kept for ornamental and decorative purposes, they are not considered not hukaf ledirah and therefore permitted. Being fenced or not, does not in this case make much of a difference, once they are included in the city eiruv.

Rabbi A. Bartfeld as revised by Horav Shlomo Miller Shlit’a

Posted 6/9/2017 3:12 PM | Tell a Friend | Ask The Rabbi | Comments (0)

Be the First to Post a Comment!
Name:* Email:**
* Names will be displayed. Anonymous comments will be filtered at a higher level.
** Email addresses will not be displayed or used.

Enter the characters from the image below.

Characters are not case-sensitive.

Sof Zman Kiddush Levanoh: Shabbos Kodesh 9:45 PM + 0 Chalakim

Toronto Eruv
Eruv status verified Friday afternoons. For email notification,  CLICK HERE

Toronto Weather

Home  |  About Us  |  Business Directory  |  Classified  |  Directory Rates  |  FAQ  |  Weekly Specials
Community Calendar  |  Davening Schedule  |  Weekly Shiurim  |  Zmanim  |  Contact Us  - Contact Us