1 
									
										 2 
									
										 3 
									
										 4 
									
										 5 
									
										 6 
									
										 7 
									
										 8 
									
										 9 
									
										 10 
									
										 11 
									
										 12 
									
										 13 
									
										 14 
									
										 15 
									
										 16 
									
										 17 
									
										 18 
									
										 19 
									
										 20 
									
										 21 
									
										 22 
									
										 23 
									
										 24 
									
										 25 
									
										 26 
									
										 27 
									
										 28 
									
										 29 
									
										 30 
									
										 31 
									
										 32 
									
										 33 
									
										 34 
									
										 35 
									
										 36 
									
										 37 
									
										 38 
									
										 39 
									
										 40 
									
										 41 
									
										 42 
									
										 43 
									
										 44 
									
										 45 
									
										 46 
									
										 47 
									
										 48 
									
										 49 
									
										 50 
									
										 51 
									
										 52 
									
										 53 
									
										 54 
									
										 55 
									
										 56 
									
										 57 
									
										 58 
									
										 59 
									
										 60 
									
										 61 
									
										 62 
									
										 63 
									
										 64 
									
										 65 
									
										 66 
									
										 67 
									
										 68 
									
										 69 
									
										 70 
									
										 71 
									
										 72 
									
										 73 
									
										 74 
									
										 75 
									
										 76 
									
										 77 
									
										 78 
									
										 79 
									
										 80 
									
										 81 
									
										 82 
									
										 83 
									
										 84 
									
										 85 
									
										 86 
									
										 87 
									
										 88 
									
										 89 
									
										 90 
									
										 91 
									
										 92 
									
										 93 
									
										 94 
									
										 95 
									
										 96 
									
										 97 
									
										 98 
									
										 99 
									
										 100 
									
										 101 
									
										 102 
									
										 103 
									
										 104 
									
										 105 
									
										 106 
									
										 107 
									
										 108 
									
										 109 
									
										 110 
									
										 111 
									
										 112 
									
										 113 
									
										 114 
									
										 115 
									
										 116 
									
										 117 
									
										 118 
									
										 119 
									
										 120 
									
										 121 
									
										 122 
									
										 123 
									
										 124 
									
										 125 
									
										 126 
									
										 127 
									
										 128 
									
										 129 
									
										 130 
									
										 131 
									
										 132 
									
										 133 
									
										 134 
									
										 135 
									
										 136 
									
										 137 
									
										 138 
									
										 139 
									
										 140 
									
										 141 
									
										 142 
									
										 143 
									
										 144 
									
										 145 
									
										 146 
									
										 147 
									
										 148 
									
										 149 
									
										 150 
									
										 151 
									
										 152 
									
										 153 
									
										 154 
									
										 155 
									
										 156 
									
										 157 
									
										 158 
									
										 159 
									
										 160 
									
										 161 
									
										 162 
									
										 163 
									
										 164 
									
										 165 
									
										 166 
									
										 167 
									
										 168 
									
										169
									
										 170 
									
										 171 
									
										 172 
									
										 173 
									
										 174 
									
										 175 
									
										 176 
									
										 177 
									
										 178 
									
										 179 
									
										 180 
									
										 181 
									
										 182 
									
										 183 
									
										 184 
									
										 185 
									
										 186 
									
										 187 
									
										 188 
									
										 189 
									
										 190 
									
										 191 
									
										 192 
									
										 193 
									
										 194 
									
										 195 
									
										 196 
									
										 197 
									
										 198 
									
										 199 
									
										 200 
									
										 201 
									
										 202 
									
										 203 
									
										 204 
									
										 205 
									
										 206 
									
										 207 
									
										 208 
									
										 209 
									
										 210 
									
										 211 
									
										 212 
									
										 213 
									
										 214 
									
										 215 
									
										 216 
									
										 217 
									
										 218 
									
										 219 
									
										 220 
									
										 221 
									
										 222 
									
										 223 
									
										 224 
									
										 225 
									
										 226 
									
										 227 
									
										 228 
									
										 229 
									
										 230 
									
										 231 
									
										 232 
									
										 233 
									
										 234 
									
										 235 
									
										 236 
									
										 237 
									
										 238 
									
										 239 
									
										 240 
									
										 241 
									
										 242 
									
										 243 
									
										 244 
									
										 245 
									
										 246 
									
										 247 
									
										 248 
									
										 249 
									
										 250 
									
										 251 
									
										 252 
									
										 253 
									
										 254 
									
										 255 
									
										 256 
									
										 257 
									
										 258 
									
										 259 
									
										 260 
									
										 261 
									
										 262 
									
										 263 
									
										 264 
									
										 265 
									
										 266 
									
										 267 
									
										 268 
									
										 269 
									
										 270 
									
										 271 
									
										 272 
									
										 273 
									
										 274 
									
										 275 
									
										 276 
									
										 277 
									
										 278 
									
										 279 
									
										 280 
									
										 281 
									
										 282 
									
										 283 
									
										 284 
									
										 285 
									
										 286 
									
										 287 
									
										 288 
									
										 289 
									
										 290 
									
										 291 
									
										 292 
									
										 293 
									
										 294 
									
										 295 
									
									 
								
						 | 
					
					
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2522   Still Immersed in the Immersion Question
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										| 
											
												Q.    Thank you for answering (question 2510). Re the last paragraph, my question was concerning fancy glass or metal dishes that are definitely meant to be reused. Can one eat directly from them if such a platter was sent for a simcha? Does it make  ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 2/4/2020 1:40 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2521   Parevenu?
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q.  Good afternoon Rabbi. I saw this (see attached picture) in the grocery store and I was thinking, I could make Kosher cheeseburgers. 
Is there any prohibition to do this?  (Attached is an image of a package of Beyond Burger, containing plant  ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/31/2020 3:23 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2520   An Open Book to Forgetfulness 
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q.  I have seen that when some people stop learning in the beis hamedresh to go temporarily outside, they turn the sefer being learned around, so the upside now faces the top of the table, is that proper? 
Others use another closed sefer and pla ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/31/2020 9:44 AM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2519   Siyum Partners in Torah
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q.  We are celebrating an important Siyum Hashas for our group of lerners in a few days. We have invited a large crowd to a catered seuda that is also a fundraising event essential for our shul.  
Sadly l'a our Maggid Shiur became severely ill a ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/31/2020 9:35 AM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2518   Pull Down a Chair?
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q. Does a son inherit the seat acquired by his father, or assigned to him as a tribute to his eminence, after the death of his father? (See question 2517 above). 
 
A.   Poskim explain that the Shulchan Aruch (Y.D. 240: 2), seems to infer t ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/30/2020 12:55 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2517     On The edge of Your Seat
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q.  Is it permitted for a son to seat himself on the place assigned to or acquired by his father in shul, when the father is not attending? 
 
A.  Talmud (Kidushun 31b) and Shulchan Aruch (Y.D. 240: 2) rule that a son should not seat on his ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/30/2020 12:52 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2516   A Mohel "Mit a Farmachten Moil"
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q.   Could an onen (one who lost a close relative, before burial) be the mohel at a bris, if no one else is available?  
 
A.  Chassam Soffer (C.M. 39) maintains that if the body of the deceased has already been transferred to the Chevra Ka ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/30/2020 12:39 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2515   Figure that Speech
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q.  Can an onen (one who lost a close relative, before burial) partake at the seuda (meal) of the bris of his grandchild?  If yes can he be asked to speak publicly. (See question 2514 above). 
 
A. Horav Shlomo Miller's opinion is that alth ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/30/2020 12:37 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2514   A Sad State of Fair
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q.   Can an onen (one who lost a close relative, before burial) be a sandak at the bris of a grandchild? 
 
A. Chidushim Uviurim (11) maintains that if the body of the deceased has already been transferred to the Chevra Kaddisha, it is perm ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/30/2020 12:34 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2513   A Shaila In Hot Water?
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										| 
											
												Q.   Is it permitted during Shabbos to open or increase the water dripping into a humidifier connected to the heating furnace. The warm air rushes by a metal net or mesh, that spreads the droplets of water into the air exiting the furnace and it evap ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/24/2020 3:33 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2512   Add And Adapt Adam?
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										| 
											
												Q. We are B'H a baal teshuva family, and Hashem just graced us with a baby boy. We want to know if we can give the name of a dear deceased grandfather named Adam to our newborn. Adam was always of great help to us and we want to honor his memory. Is  ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/23/2020 11:54 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2511    It's All In Your Mind
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										| 
											
												Q.  We recently learned in the daf that the intention for doing a mitzva deuraisa (Biblical) is essential in the compliance of the mitzva. Since during the day we do many mitzvos such as learning Torah or helping others, should one at the beginning o ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/23/2020 11:34 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2510   Immersed in this Immersion Question
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												I received a gift of prepared desserts, meant to be eaten straight from the individual glass jars that they came in.. I was told by the store personnel that the jars were already toiveled. I was advised to retoivl without a bracha. 
My question  ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/23/2020 11:21 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2509   More Intents and Purposes 
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q.   Referring back to the previous question (2496), davening before neitz standing versus sitting in the car after neitz. If there would be no difference in kavana, what would be the better option?   
 
A. Horav Shlomo Miller's Shlit'a opi ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/23/2020 10:53 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2508   Know This Like The Back Of Your Hands
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										| 
											
												Q. Often people pour down water during Netilat Yodaim on the top of their hands over their wrist, to properly cover with water the complete hand. However, as the hands are bend downward into the sink, the result is that often the water reaches the ar ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/23/2020 10:43 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2507   Right On The Right Time
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q. I see often that people when they wash hands say the bracha of "Al Netilat Yadayim" at the time they are drying their hands. Is that correct? Is it correct or commendable for one to hold the towel or paper towel in his hands at that time? 
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/23/2020 10:41 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2506   Don't Hold Your Breath
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q.  Can one use on Shabbos the new CPAP (continuous positive airway pressure) automatic apnea respirator machines that produce a soft, steady jet of air with enough pressure to keep the airway open?  
 
A.  On question 1744, we wrote: "Hora ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/20/2020 4:27 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2505   Testing One's Own Medicine
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										| 
											
												Q.  New Jersey lawmakers are expected to vote on a bill to eliminate most religious exemptions for vaccines for schoolchildren. This shot is being forced now in NJ schools. What does HoRav S. Miller  say about it? and would he side with frum refuseni ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/20/2020 12:14 AM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2504   Perls At Your Own Peril
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										| 
											
												
Q.  I'm a frum teenager and have always wanted to join Shomrim or the volunteer firefighters in our community, since they urgently require more participants. Yet my parents are very much against it and argue that al pi (following)  Halacha one shou ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/16/2020 11:58 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2503   Calculating a Calculated Risk
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										| 
											
												Q. I was invited to give a shiur for young people who are interested in becoming Baalei Teshuva and I seem to be promisingly successful. A good part why is that the area we are able to meet for the convenience of the group, is in a section of town th ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 1/16/2020 11:56 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 |