1 
									
										 2 
									
										 3 
									
										 4 
									
										 5 
									
										 6 
									
										 7 
									
										 8 
									
										 9 
									
										 10 
									
										 11 
									
										 12 
									
										 13 
									
										 14 
									
										 15 
									
										 16 
									
										 17 
									
										 18 
									
										 19 
									
										 20 
									
										 21 
									
										 22 
									
										 23 
									
										 24 
									
										 25 
									
										 26 
									
										 27 
									
										 28 
									
										 29 
									
										 30 
									
										 31 
									
										 32 
									
										 33 
									
										 34 
									
										 35 
									
										 36 
									
										 37 
									
										 38 
									
										 39 
									
										 40 
									
										 41 
									
										 42 
									
										 43 
									
										 44 
									
										 45 
									
										 46 
									
										 47 
									
										 48 
									
										 49 
									
										 50 
									
										 51 
									
										 52 
									
										 53 
									
										 54 
									
										 55 
									
										 56 
									
										 57 
									
										 58 
									
										 59 
									
										 60 
									
										 61 
									
										 62 
									
										 63 
									
										 64 
									
										 65 
									
										 66 
									
										 67 
									
										 68 
									
										 69 
									
										 70 
									
										 71 
									
										 72 
									
										 73 
									
										 74 
									
										 75 
									
										 76 
									
										 77 
									
										 78 
									
										 79 
									
										 80 
									
										 81 
									
										 82 
									
										 83 
									
										 84 
									
										 85 
									
										 86 
									
										 87 
									
										 88 
									
										 89 
									
										 90 
									
										 91 
									
										 92 
									
										 93 
									
										 94 
									
										 95 
									
										 96 
									
										 97 
									
										 98 
									
										 99 
									
										 100 
									
										 101 
									
										 102 
									
										 103 
									
										 104 
									
										 105 
									
										 106 
									
										 107 
									
										 108 
									
										 109 
									
										 110 
									
										 111 
									
										 112 
									
										 113 
									
										 114 
									
										 115 
									
										 116 
									
										 117 
									
										 118 
									
										 119 
									
										 120 
									
										 121 
									
										 122 
									
										 123 
									
										 124 
									
										 125 
									
										 126 
									
										 127 
									
										 128 
									
										 129 
									
										 130 
									
										 131 
									
										 132 
									
										 133 
									
										 134 
									
										 135 
									
										 136 
									
										 137 
									
										 138 
									
										 139 
									
										 140 
									
										 141 
									
										 142 
									
										 143 
									
										 144 
									
										 145 
									
										 146 
									
										 147 
									
										 148 
									
										149
									
										 150 
									
										 151 
									
										 152 
									
										 153 
									
										 154 
									
										 155 
									
										 156 
									
										 157 
									
										 158 
									
										 159 
									
										 160 
									
										 161 
									
										 162 
									
										 163 
									
										 164 
									
										 165 
									
										 166 
									
										 167 
									
										 168 
									
										 169 
									
										 170 
									
										 171 
									
										 172 
									
										 173 
									
										 174 
									
										 175 
									
										 176 
									
										 177 
									
										 178 
									
										 179 
									
										 180 
									
										 181 
									
										 182 
									
										 183 
									
										 184 
									
										 185 
									
										 186 
									
										 187 
									
										 188 
									
										 189 
									
										 190 
									
										 191 
									
										 192 
									
										 193 
									
										 194 
									
										 195 
									
										 196 
									
										 197 
									
										 198 
									
										 199 
									
										 200 
									
										 201 
									
										 202 
									
										 203 
									
										 204 
									
										 205 
									
										 206 
									
										 207 
									
										 208 
									
										 209 
									
										 210 
									
										 211 
									
										 212 
									
										 213 
									
										 214 
									
										 215 
									
										 216 
									
										 217 
									
										 218 
									
										 219 
									
										 220 
									
										 221 
									
										 222 
									
										 223 
									
										 224 
									
										 225 
									
										 226 
									
										 227 
									
										 228 
									
										 229 
									
										 230 
									
										 231 
									
										 232 
									
										 233 
									
										 234 
									
										 235 
									
										 236 
									
										 237 
									
										 238 
									
										 239 
									
										 240 
									
										 241 
									
										 242 
									
										 243 
									
										 244 
									
										 245 
									
										 246 
									
										 247 
									
										 248 
									
										 249 
									
										 250 
									
										 251 
									
										 252 
									
										 253 
									
										 254 
									
										 255 
									
										 256 
									
										 257 
									
										 258 
									
										 259 
									
										 260 
									
										 261 
									
										 262 
									
										 263 
									
										 264 
									
										 265 
									
										 266 
									
										 267 
									
										 268 
									
										 269 
									
										 270 
									
										 271 
									
										 272 
									
										 273 
									
										 274 
									
										 275 
									
										 276 
									
										 277 
									
										 278 
									
										 279 
									
										 280 
									
										 281 
									
										 282 
									
										 283 
									
										 284 
									
										 285 
									
										 286 
									
										 287 
									
										 288 
									
										 289 
									
										 290 
									
										 291 
									
										 292 
									
										 293 
									
										 294 
									
										 295 
									
									 
								
						 | 
					
					
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2918   Grave Burial?
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										| 
											
												
Q. I have seen some people bury plastic bags full of shemos (leftover sefarim or their pages, such as sidurim, chumashim etc.) inside street excavations done primarily for fixing water or sewage pipes. They told me that these are double plastic bag ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 11/5/2020 10:30 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2917   Stop and Listen?  
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q. If one in the middle of Shemonesrei hears the laud answering by the congregation of the 13 Middos, should he momentarily stop his recitation and have in his mind answering with them as one is supposed to do when hearing Kaddish or Keddusha? 
 ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 11/5/2020 10:13 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											#   2916   A Vort on a Vort
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q. The minhag in our family is to avoid making weddings during the month of Marcheshvan. Does that include also making a vort (compromise)? 
 
A. On question 1183 we wrote; "There are Poskim who maintain that one should avoid being wedded d ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 11/5/2020 10:05 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2915   Spirit Away
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q. Can one use peeled garlic cloves that are imported from China and packaged in vacuum sealed plastic bags, since the obviously stayed overnight peeled, which we avoid? 
 
A. On question 1366 regarding leaving overnight an onion, we wrote; ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 11/5/2020 10:00 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2914   Reason to Listen
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										| 
											
												Q. During the reading of the Torah on Shabbat, sometimes I loose concentration and miss hearing or paying attention to some words and even psukim of the leinning (reading). Was I yotze (complied with) the reading? Should I then try to listen again to ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 11/5/2020 9:48 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2913  Celebrating  Dia de los Muertos?
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										| 
											
												Q.  Dear Rabbi; As you probably well know, in Mexico instead of Halloween, people celebrate the next day the "Dia de los Muertos"  or the Day of Dead, which is remarkably different. Often candles, flowers and the favorite foods of the deceased are pl ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 11/3/2020 6:33 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2912   Good Things Come to those Who Wait
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										| 
											
												Q.  I have been learning in a Kolel in Yerushalaim for several years. I'm married with two small children and was offered a position as a rabbi and teacher for three years in a Latin American country where I grew up. Although this is a great opportun ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 11/1/2020 12:40 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2911   Missed the Boat?
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q.  Why is the ark of Noah called a Teiva. Considering its purpose would it not be more correct to call it, an Oniya, (as by Yona and Chiram) or the Targum’s S’finah, meaning a boat or ship? 
 
A.  The simple answer would be that a Teiva wa ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 11/1/2020 12:27 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2910   This Is News to Me 
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										| 
											
												Q. I usually get my news from a usual Bnei Torah accepted news web site, that many frum people use. Yet recently there was a video posted of a speech given by the Israeli Prime Minister delivered during Shabbos. Is it permitted to view or listen to t ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 11/1/2020 12:09 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2909   Happy Birthday
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q. See question 2904 on birthday celebrations above. If one is allowed to, what would be a proper way of celebrating a birthday? 
 
A. Different traditions and customs are mentioned for those who do celebrate birthdays. Some Gedolim would m ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 11/1/2020 11:56 AM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2908   Catch Your Name
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										| 
											
												Q.  A bochur who became a Baal Teshuva and learns today in a yeshiva was born and raised as a Muslim and went to a Islamic Madrasah. When he became aware that his mother was actually Jewish and he also visited the grave of her father and mother in a  ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 11/1/2020 11:41 AM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2907   A Hot Shailah
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q. Can one use a heat-pack or pad outside during Shabbos to keep warm when davening in a backyard minyan? Can one use battery heated socks to be used during Shabbos 
. 
A. Heat packs or pads can provide heat by a chemical exothermic reactio ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 10/30/2020 12:25 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2906   Security Blanket
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										| 
											
												Q. During these pandemic times when still many, despite the cold weather, daven on outside backyard minyanim, and seek ways to keep warm even during the longer tefilos of Shabbos, a number of questions have been raised. Firstly, can one wrap himself  ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 10/30/2020 12:25 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2905   The Slipping Mask 
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q. I have a question regarding wearing masks to shul. 
 
We have a few female  members of our shul who don't carry and don't want to wear a mask outside when they walk to shul because they feel its carrying.  My question is, is it carrying  ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 10/29/2020 2:38 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2904   This Takes the Cake
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												
Q.  Shalom Harav,  We are currently learning Chukos HaAkum in the Link Kollel in Los Angeles under Rabbi Lebhar. 
It was brought to our attention that birthday cakes and candles have a possible source in avoda Zara. If the source is avoda zar ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 10/29/2020 1:45 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2903   Crumble the Crumbs
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q.  In Ask the Rabbi question30 you write: 
"(It is still prohibited to tread with your feet on the crumbs on the floor, Mishnah Berurah 180, 10)" 
But doesn't the MB (444:15) write that you may walk on the crumbs?  
 
A. On quest ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 10/28/2020 2:50 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2902   Up a Tree?
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												 Q.   In Ask the Rabbi question 35, the Rav recommends avoiding cutting down a fruit tree, it seems even if it no longer bears fruit. 
However, it is clear in the Rambam (Hilchos M'lochim 6:9) that one can even cut down a date tree if it still g ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 10/28/2020 2:34 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2901   Abandon Ship?
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										| 
											
												Q.  K'vod Harav,  I was in a shul with exactly ten people and four already davened. I was of those that had not davened. However, I am makpid to daven with asara mispallelim, as numerous poskim hold it is not tefilla b'tzibbur unless there are asara  ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 10/27/2020 1:23 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2900  Has this Dawned on You?
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q. Regarding the above questions (2898-99) on davening before dawn. Can one say Pesukei Dezimra before the alos (dawn)? 
 
A. Sha'arei Teshuva (664) quotes Maharil that one should avoid saying Pesukei Dezimara at night, Mekadeh Yisroel (Sha ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 10/23/2020 4:34 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 | 
						
	
						
		
					
						
							 | 
							 
								
									
								
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
									
										
											 
											# 2899   Something New Under the Sun?
										 | 
										
										
										 | 
									 
									
										 | 
									 
									
										
											
												Q.  In places where the netz hachama (sunrise) is very late, may one daven shacharis at alos  (dawn - or even earlier) on a consistent basis? How much before neitz is considered alos?  
 
A.  (See question 2898 above regarding the re ....
											
										 | 
									 
								 
							 | 
						
			
						
							 | 
							 | 
							 | 
							
								
   
								Posted 10/23/2020 1:00 PM |   
								Tell a Friend
								 | Ask The Rabbi | 
								
								
								Comments (0)
								
								
  
							 | 
						
							
						
							| 
															
							 |